对涉外定牌加工行为的再思考——以知识产权海关保护执法实践为视角
发布时间：2019-04-02 13:46
【摘要】：近年来,涉外定牌加工是否构成侵权,在司法界、理论界一直争论不休,相关案例的判决结果也各不相同,不仅给行政执法领域的执法者带来诸多困惑,也给承揽加工企业、境内外商标注册人带来诸多困扰。关于涉外定牌加工行为是否构成侵权,先前已有诸多学者、专家撰文阐述,现从海关执法实践出发,通过梳理近年来海关查获的涉外定牌加工案例及相关案例法院判决情况,进行利弊分析,对如何优化涉外定牌加工行为侵权与否的认定程序和标准展开讨论;提出应以我国商标权地域性作为认定涉外定牌加工是否构成侵权的主要原则,同时将违反诚实信用原则的情形予以例外处置,并引入反担保放行、简易程序等进一步优化对涉外定牌加工案件的处理程序,以期进一步平衡双方当事人权利义务,积极推进建立公平、有序、健康的市场经济秩序。
[Abstract]:In recent years, whether foreign-related licensing processing constitutes infringement or not, in the judicial circles, the theoretical circle has been debating endlessly, and the judgment results of related cases are different, which not only brings a lot of confusion to the enforcers in the field of administrative law enforcement, but also brings a lot of confusion to the contracting and processing enterprises. Domestic and foreign trademark registrants bring a lot of trouble. As to whether the processing of foreign-related licensing constitutes infringement, many scholars and experts have written about it before, and now, starting from the practice of customs enforcement, through combing the foreign-related licensing processing cases and related cases seized by the customs in recent years, the court has ruled on the situation. Carry on the pros and cons analysis, discuss how to optimize the procedure and the standard of determining the infringement or not of the foreign-related brand-fixing processing; It is proposed that the regionality of trademark rights in China should be taken as the main principle to determine whether the processing of foreign-related licensing constitutes infringement, and at the same time, the violation of the principle of good faith should be exceptionally dealt with, and the anti-guarantee release should be introduced. In order to further balance the rights and obligations of both parties, and actively promote the establishment of a fair, orderly and healthy market economy order, the summary procedure further optimizes the processing procedure of foreign-related licensing cases.
【作者单位】： 上海海关法规处;
【分类号】：D923.43
[Abstract]:In recent years, whether foreign-related licensing processing constitutes infringement or not, in the judicial circles, the theoretical circle has been debating endlessly, and the judgment results of related cases are different, which not only brings a lot of confusion to the enforcers in the field of administrative law enforcement, but also brings a lot of confusion to the contracting and processing enterprises. Domestic and foreign trademark registrants bring a lot of trouble. As to whether the processing of foreign-related licensing constitutes infringement, many scholars and experts have written about it before, and now, starting from the practice of customs enforcement, through combing the foreign-related licensing processing cases and related cases seized by the customs in recent years, the court has ruled on the situation. Carry on the pros and cons analysis, discuss how to optimize the procedure and the standard of determining the infringement or not of the foreign-related brand-fixing processing; It is proposed that the regionality of trademark rights in China should be taken as the main principle to determine whether the processing of foreign-related licensing constitutes infringement, and at the same time, the violation of the principle of good faith should be exceptionally dealt with, and the anti-guarantee release should be introduced. In order to further balance the rights and obligations of both parties, and actively promote the establishment of a fair, orderly and healthy market economy order, the summary procedure further optimizes the processing procedure of foreign-related licensing cases.
【作者单位】： 上海海关法规处;
【分类号】：D923.43
【参考文献】
相关期刊论文 前1条
1 张伟君;魏立舟;赵勇;;涉外定牌加工在商标法中的法律性质——兼论商标侵权构成的判定[J];知识产权;2014年02期
【共引文献】
相关期刊论文 前4条
1 周详;魏征;;“涉外定牌加工”争论几时休[J];中华商标;2014年10期
2 苗鑫;;定牌加工中的商标侵权分析[J];法制与社会;2015年15期
3 刘冬;;涉外定牌加工中的商标侵权问题分析[J];经济视角(上旬刊);2014年05期
4 曾亦栋;;论涉外定牌加工商标侵权问题的海关处理[J];海关与经贸研究;2015年03期
相关会议论文 前1条
1 李亚莉;戴国琛;;中国涉外定牌加工的商标侵权认定[A];全面提升服务能力，建设知识产权强国——2015年中华全国专利代理人协会年会第六届知识产权论坛优秀论文集[C];2015年
相关硕士学位论文 前2条
1 管晓婷;涉外定牌加工商标侵权问题研究[D];华东政法大学;2014年
2 张sナ，
本文编号：2452610
本文链接：https://www.wllwen.com/falvlunwen/minfalunwen/2452610.html
