管辖权竞争与当代中国乡村司法的合法性建构

发布时间：2018-04-08 11:18

本文选题：乡村司法　切入点：纠纷解决　出处：《当代法学》2014年04期

【摘要】：通过对乡村司法现状的田野考察发现,乡村社会依然存在着司法形态多元化特点。然而,多元化并不必然带来乡村司法的有序化。究其原因,不同的司法形态在管辖权问题上存在着隐性的竞争关系。因为这种竞争关系的存在,乡村司法资源供给错综复杂,乡村司法结构混乱,这些情况都不利于乡村司法的合法性建构和乡村秩序的重建。研究表明:乡村司法的合法性建构不仅仅只是国家权力和符号权力的建构,更应该是一种具体实践意义上的合法性建构。这种合法性建构要求以多元司法知识为基础,以行动者需求为导向,通过非正式司法的伦理重建和正式司法的权限界定来实现乡村司法资源供给的合理配置,并使民众能够更好地"接近司法"。
[Abstract]:Through the field investigation of the current situation of rural justice, it is found that the rural society still has the pluralistic characteristics of judicial form.However, diversification does not necessarily lead to the ordering of rural justice.The reason is that there is a recessive competitive relationship in jurisdiction in different judicial forms.Because of the existence of this competitive relationship, the supply of rural judicial resources is complicated, and the rural judicial structure is chaotic, which is not conducive to the construction of the legitimacy of rural justice and the reconstruction of rural order.The research shows that the construction of rural justice legitimacy is not only the construction of state power and symbol power, but also the construction of legitimacy in practical sense.The construction of legitimacy requires that the rational allocation of rural judicial resources should be realized through the ethical reconstruction of informal justice and the definition of jurisdiction of formal justice, based on pluralistic judicial knowledge and oriented by the needs of the actors.And better access to justice.
【作者单位】：云南大学法学院;
【基金】：云南省教育厅科学研究基金重点项目“法治框架下边疆治理模式创新的理论与实践研究”(2013Z061)的阶段性成果
【分类号】：D920.4

【参考文献】