论案件质量评估制度的功能预期与超负

发布时间：2018-07-07 21:17

  本文选题：中国司法改革 + 案件质量评估制度　； 参考：《学习与探索》2017年05期

【摘要】：目前我国所建立的案件质量评估制度,旨在以量化的方式对整体司法活动进行考核、汇总与引导,其涵盖当前技术水平、认知水平进步所带来的福利,目的是促使审判管理实现科学化、精细化和系统化的转型。但在现有条件下,案件质量评估制度却无法实现设计者的主观意图,制度设计的失误与指标治理的困境阻碍了制度预期的“指挥棒”功能的发挥。实际上,案件质量评估制度根本就没有能力满足社会的此种功能需求,功能互惠结构中的案件质量评估制度受到结构的宰制而失去了功能自主,反而产生出强化司法行政化的隐性功能。
[Abstract]:At present, the case quality evaluation system established in our country aims to assess, aggregate and guide the overall judicial activities in a quantitative way. It covers the benefits brought about by the current technological level and the progress of cognitive level. The purpose is to promote the scientific, refined and systematic transformation of trial management. However, under the existing conditions, the case quality evaluation system can not realize the subjective intention of the designer, and the system design errors and the predicaments of index governance hinder the expected "baton" function of the system. In fact, the case quality assessment system simply does not have the ability to meet the functional needs of society, and the case quality assessment system in the functional reciprocal structure is ruled by the structure and loses its functional autonomy. On the contrary, it produces a recessive function of strengthening the administration of justice.
，

本文编号：2106301