博弈、挣脱与民意——从“双非”风波回望“庄丰源案”

发布时间：2018-06-09 00:52

本文选题：“双非” + 庄丰源案　；参考：《政治与法律》2012年06期

【摘要】：庄丰源案是特区政府与法律精英的博弈,政府方面的败诉一方面在于人大释法技术上的不成熟以及入境处在诉讼策略上的失误,另一方面在于终审法院的某种挣脱情绪,这种挣脱情绪是基于不受干预的自治要求和最大限度的权利保护倾向。"双非"风波之后,法律精英的胜利显得黯淡。法律追求不应忽视社会效果,法院不能轻易抛弃保守原则,否则可能会带来较大的社会风险。中央需要加强法律解释技术的修炼并增进与香港的及时沟通。香港法院应该从这次事件中吸取教训。
[Abstract]:The Chuang Fengyuan case is a game between the SAR government and the legal elite. On the one hand, the defeat of the government lies in the immaturity of the NPC interpretation of the law and the mistakes made by the Immigration Department in the litigation strategy; on the other hand, it lies in a certain kind of free mood on the part of the Court of final Appeal. This breakaway is based on an uninterventionist demand for autonomy and a tendency to maximize the protection of rights. " After the storm, the victory of the legal elite looked bleak. The legal pursuit should not ignore the social effect, the court cannot abandon the conservative principle easily, otherwise may bring the social risk. The central authorities need to strengthen legal interpretation techniques and enhance timely communication with Hong Kong. Hong Kong courts should learn from this incident.
【作者单位】：北京大学法学院;
【分类号】：D669;D922.14;D921.9

【二级参考文献】