行政合法性与合理性的二律背反及其消解方式——以房产“限购令”的存废为例

发布时间：2018-01-18 16:09

本文关键词：行政合法性与合理性的二律背反及其消解方式——以房产“限购令”的存废为例　出处：《中共福建省委党校学报》2015年06期 　论文类型：期刊论文

【摘要】：随着大部分城市松绑房产"限购令",限购的合法性、合理性问题,再次成为舆论的热点问题。有学者主张,"限购令"会使楼市走向理性、健康发展之路,并没有违背经济正义精神,应在高房价城市推行。有学者则认为,"限购令"的出台本身是缺乏法律依据的,应当以房地产市场的自我调节为主。从行政合法性原则与合理性原则的角度,对房产"限购令"进行分析,发现房产"限购令"既契合行政合理性原则,亦违背了行政合法性原则,这两个相互矛盾的命题实际上都有立足依据。通过完善保障房政策、完善司法救济体系等方式,或可有效协调这两个命题。
[Abstract]:With most cities untying real estate "purchase restrictions", the issue of the legitimacy and rationality of the purchase restrictions has once again become a hot issue of public opinion. Some scholars argue that the "purchase restriction order" will lead the property market to a rational and healthy way of development. There is no violation of the spirit of economic justice, should be implemented in high-price cities. Some scholars believe that the introduction of "purchase restrictions" itself is lack of legal basis. From the angle of the principle of administrative legality and rationality, this paper analyzes the "purchase restriction order" of real estate, and finds that the "purchase restriction order" accords with the principle of administrative rationality. It also violates the principle of administrative legality, and these two contradictory propositions are actually based on the basis. By perfecting indemnificatory apartment's policy and judicial relief system, these two propositions may be effectively coordinated.
【作者单位】：宜宾学院;
【分类号】：D922.1;D922.29
【正文快照】： 一、房产“限购令”法律性质及其存废之争2015年4月16日,佛山市政府常务会议发布了《关于保持经济稳定增长的若干意见》,提出全面取消房产“限购令”,成为广东倒数第三个取消“限购令”的城市1[1];而在坚持“限购令”不放松的一线城市中,政府也计划调整限购与户籍匹配的政策。

【参考文献】