“益昱祥诉成明案”分析——重点明晰完全赔偿原则中可得利益

发布时间：2018-05-21 19:17

本文选题：违约责任 + 损害赔偿　；参考：《法制与社会》2012年09期

【摘要】：民法被广泛地理解为"生活法",作为民法重要组成部分的合同法,是调整市场经济关系的基本法,其实用性强的特点更是突出。当因合同发生纠纷,运用合同法及相关法律规范来处理分歧,使合同双方的利益保持均衡,是合同法的重要使命和价值所在。上海益昱祥投资管理有限公司与甘肃成明建筑工程公司之间的诉讼,原告主张赔偿数额较大且双方争议内容集中。但双方所持立场却差异较大。在这种情况下如何以双方均能接受的方式合理处理案件,考验了以法律分析案情的能力。关于可得利益,法律上支持但要求严格。满足法律规定的可得利益是对非违约方损失的合理补偿,但不具备条件的可得利益主张对另一方显失公平。从法律本身出发,寻找可得利益的现实规定,从法理角度解释规定的合理性,才能恰当地解决这一纠纷。
[Abstract]:Civil law is widely understood as "life law". As an important part of civil law, contract law is the basic law to adjust the relationship between market economy. When disputes arise due to contract, it is the important mission and value of contract law to use contract law and relevant legal norms to deal with differences and to balance the interests of both parties. In the lawsuit between Shanghai Yiyuxiang Investment Management Co., Ltd and Gansu Chengming Construction Engineering Company, the plaintiff claimed that the amount of compensation was large and the contents of the dispute between the two sides were concentrated. But the positions of both sides are quite different. In this case, how to deal with the case reasonably in a way acceptable to both sides tests the ability of analyzing the case by law. There is legal support but strict requirements with regard to available benefits. To satisfy the available benefits stipulated by law is the reasonable compensation for the loss of the non-defaulting party, but the unqualified obtainable interest claims that it is unfair to the other party. From the point of view of law itself, the author tries to find the realistic regulation of the available interests and explain the reasonableness of the stipulation from the angle of legal theory, so that the dispute can be solved properly.
【作者单位】：甘肃政法学院;中天律师事务所;
【分类号】：D923.6

【共引文献】